Reviewed: 10th December 2018
Phoenix company fraud occurs when the directors of an insolvent company, or one that’s approaching insolvency, deliberately prevent the company’s creditors receiving payment for monies owed.
It’s a situation that can cause severe financial distress for the individual creditors and trade creditors involved, and an issue to which HMRC pays close attention. Insolvency laws in the UK state that when a company enters insolvency its directors must place the interests of creditors first to minimise their losses, and phoenix company fraud goes directly against this law.
To confuse the issue a little, the term ‘phoenix company’ is also commonly associated with a legitimate insolvency process called pre pack administration, which requires the appointment of a licensed insolvency practitioner (IP).
Although at face value the scenario seems to be similar, under the right circumstances pre pack administration can provide the highest returns for creditors when compared with other processes.
A phoenix company is one that literally ‘rises from the ashes’ of another company, when existing directors buy the underlying assets. As we mentioned earlier the term can be used to describe a new company that emerges during pre pack administration – a procedure that often saves jobs and prevents other businesses suffering the common ‘ripple effect’ of insolvency.
In this process, once a buyer has been identified, a licensed insolvency practitioner is appointed who must be able to prove that ‘pre pack’ provides the best return for creditors. Pre pack administration is governed by strict rules and regulations designed to prevent the deliberate avoidance of a company’s obligations to its creditors – in other words, phoenix company fraud.
Phoenix company fraud occurs when existing directors transfer the underlying assets of their struggling company below market value, as the company approaches insolvency or when it has become insolvent.
The directors set up a similar type of business, termed a ‘newco,’ disregarding the debts of the old company and their responsibilities to its creditors. As a result, creditors of the former company typically receive little or no return - their debts are written off, and the potential for a knock-on effect of financial distress to other companies arises.
Some directors avoid their responsibilities by continually starting new companies in this way, moving on from struggling businesses without paying their creditors. So what are the ramifications for directors found guilty of phoenix company fraud?
Under UK insolvency and company law, phoenix company fraud is an extremely serious matter and directors face severe consequences if found guilty. These could include:
Company fraud is a criminal matter and directors face a prison sentence if found guilty, potentially in addition to other penalties.
Directors may be held personally liable for some or all of the company’s debts – depending on an individual’s financial circumstances, therefore, the threat of personal bankruptcy arises.
Under the Company Directors Disqualification Act, 1986, directors may be disqualified for a period of 2-15 years by order of the court. This means they’re banned from the office of director of UK companies and companies overseas that have links with the UK, and cannot be involved in setting up, marketing, or running a company.
If you’re worried about phoenix company fraud, or would like to find out more about this complex area of business, Real Business Rescue can help. We’re a major part of Begbies Traynor Group, the UK’s largest professional services consultancy. Please call one of our licensed insolvency practitioners to arrange a free same-day consultation – we operate from more than 70 offices nationwide.
21st March 2019
A significant proportion of small businesses around the UK lack the resources or the capacity to prepare themselves for the potential ramifications of a No Deal Brexit.Read More
20th March 2019
Bolton Wanderers Football Club has been told by a High Court judge that it has two weeks in which to settle its debts or it could be issued with a winding up order and sent out of business.Read More