0800 644 6080
Call FREE from Landline and Mobile
Est. 1989

HMRC Faced with Record Number of Calls for Judicial Reviews

Written by: Keith Tully

Published: 30th June 2017


An unprecedented number of applications were made for judicial reviews against HMRC during 2016, according to the London-based law firm RPC.

A total of 90 such reviews were called for over the course of last year, which represents an increase from 76 in 2015 and from just 42 in 2014.

RPC has suggested that the increase is a consequence of HMRC’s use of Accelerated Payment Notices (APNs), which effectively demand upfront payment of disputed tax amounts within 90 days.

Recipients of APNs can be either businesses or individuals, with many having been contractors from within the IT and medical professions.

According to RPC, the rise in the number of calls for judicial review raises questions about whether HMRC has been misusing the powers afforded to it as a tax-gathering organisation via APN mechanisms.

APNs are designed to function as a means of helping HMRC cut down on tax avoidance among individuals and businesses operating in the UK but their use over the past few years has been controversial.

As many as 70,000 APNs have been issued in recent years and HMRC says they have been responsible for bringing in more than £3 billion.

RPC says that the amounts of money involved in cases being disputed through calls for judicial review vary from small scale disputes involving individuals and much larger scale cases involving big businesses.

“HMRC has a duty to act fairly and lawfully, but more and more taxpayers are finding that it is falling short of the mark,” said Adam Craggs, a partner and head of tax disputes with RPC.

“With the new powers it has gained in the last few years, it is important that HMRC exercises its powers in a reasonable manner.”

A spokesperson for HMRC said in a statement: “Accelerated payments have changed the economics of tax avoidance by requiring those under investigation for tax avoidance to pay the disputed tax upfront, putting them in the same position as the majority of taxpayers who pay first and dispute later.”

“HMRC has won all five judicial reviews decided by the courts on the accelerated payments regime,” the spokesperson added.

Keith Tully

Keith Tully

Join Keith Tully on Linked In Follow Keith Tully on Twitter

Keith has been involved in Business Rescue since 1992, during which time he’s worked for both independent and national firms. His specialties include company restructuring matters and negotiating with HMRC on his clients behalf.

Meet our Team of Experts
Director Support - Business suffering from Cash-Flow Problems?
If your company is financially distressed, we also offer the below services:
Business debt recovery

  • Recover Unpaid Invoices of £5k+
  • Expert Credit Control Services
  • Stop Late Payers & Bad Debts
Visit Site
Time to pay experts

  • Get Breathing Space with HMRC
  • Support with Business Tax Arrears
  • 35 Years HMRC Negotiation
Visit Site
UK Business Finance

  • Rejected for a CBILS Loan?
  • Get Emergency Business Funding
  • Supporting 1000+ UK Companies
Visit Site
Who we help
  • Company Directors
  • Finance Directors
  • Sole Traders
  • Accountants
  • Small Businesses
  • Large Businesses
  • Partnerships
Contact our team
Jonathan Munnery
Gillian Sayburn
Julie Palmer
or Find your Nearest Office

Here at Real Business Rescue we take your privacy seriously and will only use your personal information to contact you with regards to your enquiry. We will not use your information for marketing purposes. See PRIVACY POLICY

Business Rescue Advice for Directors
Free Guide for Limited Company Directors
Business Rescue Advice for Directors
  • How to manage company cash flow problems
  • Advice on dealing with HMRC
  • Understanding rescue and closure options
  • And much more...
Free Guide Download
Dealing with your Insolvent Clients
Business Rescue Guide for Accountants
Dealing with your Insolvent Clients
  • Helping you advise insolvent clients
  • Spotting signs of client distress
  • Exploring business rescue options
  • And much more...
Free Guide Download
Our numbers speak for themselves
Number of UK Offices
Directors Helped
Licensed Insolvency Practitioners