Updated: 9th September 2021
Winding up a company in a franchise agreement can be a complex process, with several issues coming into play that would not arise during ‘standard’ company liquidation. This is true whether the company to be liquidated is the franchisor or franchisee, as each party has to deal with their own unique problems as a result of their partner going out of business.
Here we look at some of these issues, how they might be dealt with, and whether it’s possible to get out of a franchise agreement.
When a franchisee company can no longer pay its debts and enters insolvency, the franchise agreement is generally terminated as a matter of course. Many franchisors include this automatic termination clause in their contract to limit the damage to their own financial situation.
Closing a limited company with debts means that the appointed liquidator takes control of franchisee assets, and sells them to raise funds for the company’s creditors. This is the principal role of a liquidator, along with assessing the company’s liabilities such as their existing contracts.
Under the Insolvency Act, 1986, onerous contracts may be terminated by a liquidator to facilitate the winding up of an insolvent company. Onerous contracts are seen as a financial burden to a company, and the liquidator’s right to revoke them can provide greater returns for creditors as a whole.
The payment of fees is inherent in every franchise agreement, and forms the basis for a franchisee to operate using the company’s name and other intellectual property. If the office-holder decides to disclaim this agreement, the franchisor becomes an unsecured creditor for any fees and charges that remain unpaid.
Unfortunately for the franchisor, this places them at the bottom of the hierarchy for repayment, and means they may not receive any financial return from the liquidation process.
A further issue can arise for the franchisor in terms of their franchisee’s business premises. In a franchise arrangement, it’s often the case that business premises are sub-let to the franchisee company by the franchisor, who holds the ‘head lease.’
The holder of the head lease then becomes responsible for any rent arrears incurred by the insolvent franchisee. This can cause further financial difficulty for a franchisor that may not even have been aware that insolvency was looming for their franchise partner.
As we mentioned earlier, part of a liquidator’s role is to identify and take control of company assets. Due to the nature of a franchise agreement, on the financial demise of a franchisor, the company’s intellectual property which plays a crucial part in the success of franchisee partners, will be regarded as a major asset by the office-holder.
Company assets, including intellectual property such as the patents, trademarks and designs, on which the business was originally built, must be sold for the benefit of creditors. In these cases, the franchisee partners may be able to purchase the intellectual property in their own right, and proceed in business without the franchisor.
Can a franchisee terminate a franchise agreement?
The rights of franchisees to end a franchise agreement are generally very limited, and often only relate to a franchisor’s conduct. This might include instances of failing to fulfil an obligation that is fundamental to being able to operate on the most basic level.
Another example of when a franchise agreement might be regarded as repudiated, is when a franchisee is not provided access to computer systems or equipment needed to carry on their business.
When a franchisor can exit a franchise agreement
Franchise agreements generally include a clause that allows the franchisor to protect their business and terminate the agreement, or when the agreement automatically terminates. This usually happens on the insolvency of a franchisee, or when a serious breach of contract has taken place.
In some cases, franchisors allow their franchise partners an opportunity to rectify their breach, and if this doesn’t happen, they then terminate the contract.
If you’re concerned about the financial position of your franchise partner, Real Business Rescue will provide the professional advice you need. With 100 offices stretching from Inverness down to Exeter, Real Business Rescue can offer unparalleled director advice across the UK., and can arrange an initial appointment free-of-charge.
13th October 2021
The Bank of England has said it anticipates that rates of corporate insolvency will increase in the coming weeks following the removal of restrictions on winding up petitions.Read More